计算化学公社

标题: 投ACS被返回来修改重复率 [打印本页]

作者
Author:
younggood    时间: 2018-5-27 21:18
标题: 投ACS被返回来修改重复率
最近投ACS的文章,还没有送审被编辑返回来说重复率太高,让我们修改,说的很严肃,请问我修改完后该怎么给编辑回信呢,有没有经历过类似的大神们,把你们的回信发给我让我参考一下吧,非常感谢!

作者
Author:
yflchx    时间: 2018-5-28 07:31
在Cover Letter里先做说明,

把修改的地方改成红颜色的字,做成PDF,放到Supporting Information for Review Only里面。这样可行?

我没遇到过类似的事,只是觉得这样也许可行。
作者
Author:
chiweijie    时间: 2018-5-28 08:07
可以跟编辑要一下查重报告,然后认真修改重复部分,再次投稿的时候,如方便可提供给编辑一个正规的查重报告。
作者
Author:
mol    时间: 2018-5-28 08:52
遇到过类似的问题
编辑回复:Thank you for submitting your manuscript for publication in The Journal of Physical Chemistry. I do not think that further review is needed. However, ACS Publications has implemented screening of all revised manuscripts using the Cross Check plagiarism detection software from iThenticate. The Cross Check report for your manuscript was returned with an unacceptably high score of 34% overlap. You will notice that the overlap mostly refers to material in the Methods section of your paper, and much of it refers to phrases that can be found in your earlier papers. We are therefore returning your manuscript so that you can rewrite the offending portions of your paper to reduce overlap.

我就简单回了两句:We have rewrote the offending portions to reduce overlap especially the Simulation Method section. All the modifications in the revised manuscripts were marked in blue.

因为主要是和自己以前的文章模拟方法部分重复,所以我感觉问题不太大,就简单改了改,供参考。
作者
Author:
younggood    时间: 2018-5-28 09:51
mol 发表于 2018-5-28 08:52
遇到过类似的问题
编辑回复:Thank you for submitting your manuscript for publication in The Journal  ...

非常感谢




欢迎光临 计算化学公社 (http://bbs.keinsci.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3