计算化学公社

标题: 这种reject理由是不是就是文章水平还是不够的套话呢 [打印本页]

作者
Author:
li447fan    时间: 2021-4-21 14:42
标题: 这种reject理由是不是就是文章水平还是不够的套话呢
After a preliminary review of  your paper   we have the following comments:
Due to the large numbers of received submissions we decided to give the priority to the most novel papers that cover  interdisciplinary energy subjects and that deal with more advanced technologies. Also, please note that ECM covers   a wide range of general subjects and   sub-subjects. The journal is not specialized in the subject of your submission  only but we are supposed to give a balanced and fair share to all covered subjects. Currently, the journal is overloaded with submissions in the subject of your paper.   Your paper is better to be submitted to a more specialized  Elsevier Journal.  A suitable journal can be found among your references.  As a result, we decided to return your submission without review processing. Please understand that this decision has nothing to do with the technical content of the paper or its value to the archival literature. If you have more suitable papers, we invite you to submit them for consideration. Thank you again for sending this


作者
Author:
niobium    时间: 2021-4-21 14:46
拒稿不就是不够水平么,或者说是编辑觉得不够水平。。还能有啥原因
作者
Author:
li447fan    时间: 2021-4-21 15:10
niobium 发表于 2021-4-21 14:46
拒稿不就是不够水平么,或者说是编辑觉得不够水平。。还能有啥原因

就是比如方向不符啥的……
作者
Author:
sobereva    时间: 2021-4-21 16:13
li447fan 发表于 2021-4-21 15:10
就是比如方向不符啥的……

如果这个期刊有当前这篇文章类似研究方向的文章发表,说明这纯粹就是套话,编辑嫌文章level不够,或者内容亮点不够
作者
Author:
li447fan    时间: 2021-4-21 16:20
sobereva 发表于 2021-4-21 16:13
如果这个期刊有当前这篇文章类似研究方向的文章发表,说明这纯粹就是套话,编辑嫌文章level不够,或者内 ...

谢谢sob




欢迎光临 计算化学公社 (http://bbs.keinsci.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3