计算化学公社

 找回密码 Forget password
 注册 Register
Views: 8375|回复 Reply: 3
打印 Print 上一主题 Last thread 下一主题 Next thread

[xtb] Problem with opt convergence using XTB

[复制链接 Copy URL]

205

帖子

0

威望

2203

eV
积分
2408

Level 5 (御坂)

本帖最后由 rpestana94 于 2021-7-12 12:03 编辑

Greetings, I'm trying to do an optimization using XTB, in my system, I have an NMA molecule with 17 molecules of solvent, for the solvent, I'm using ChCl3, H2O, DMSO, acetonitrile, hexane, toluene, methanol, and tetrahydrofuran.

The final goal is to do a frequency calculation, with all solvents I can do it but when I'm using tetrahydrofuran, the opt does not converge with the 17 molecules, for some reason converges just with 11 molecules. The energy from one step to another goes higher and higher and the structure looks fine. I don't know what is happening, if any of you have any idea of what is going on I really appreciate it.

I'm using the default parameter and executing xtb like this:
xtb file.pdb -I xtb.inp --gbsa Thf --ohess --uhf 1

Thanks in advance.

The picture show how the energy goes higher and higher

sorry for the bad quality of the picture.

5万

帖子

99

威望

5万

eV
积分
112354

管理员

公社社长

4#
发表于 Post on 2021-7-14 16:13:19 | 只看该作者 Only view this author
rpestana94 发表于 2021-7-13 22:54
I'm using --uhf 1 because I have NMA with 17 molecules of solvent.

But the problem where solve ...

-uhf 1 corresponds to doublet, this impossibly corresponds to your actual case. You should fix this problem first.
北京科音自然科学研究中心http://www.keinsci.com)致力于计算化学的发展和传播,长期开办高质量的各种计算化学类培训:初级量子化学培训班中级量子化学培训班高级量子化学培训班量子化学波函数分析与Multiwfn程序培训班分子动力学与GROMACS培训班CP2K第一性原理计算培训班,内容介绍以及往届资料购买请点击相应链接查看。这些培训是计算化学从零快速入门以及进一步全面系统性提升研究水平的高速路!培训各种常见问题见《北京科音办的培训班FAQ》
欢迎加入“北京科音”微信公众号获取北京科音培训的最新消息、避免错过网上有价值的计算化学文章!
欢迎加入人气非常高、专业性特别强的综合性理论与计算化学交流QQ群“思想家公社QQ群”:1号:18616395,2号:466017436,3号:764390338,搜索群号能搜到哪个说明目前哪个能加,合计9000人。北京科音培训班的学员在群中可申请VIP头衔,提问将得到群主Sobereva的最优先解答。
思想家公社的门口Blog:http://sobereva.com(发布大量原创计算化学相关博文)
Multiwfn主页:http://sobereva.com/multiwfn(十分强大的量子化学波函数分析程序)
ResearchGate:https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Tian_Lu
Money and papers are rubbish, get a real life!

205

帖子

0

威望

2203

eV
积分
2408

Level 5 (御坂)

3#
 楼主 Author| 发表于 Post on 2021-7-13 22:54:56 | 只看该作者 Only view this author
sobereva 发表于 2021-7-13 03:14
NMA is a singlet molecule, why did you set --uhf 1?

I'm using --uhf 1 because I have NMA with 17 molecules of solvent.

But the problem where solve by adjusting the Electronic temperature of convergence of MD, my advisor give the solution and to be honest I don't know why this work, professor sob do you have a paper or an explanation of what is this parameter?

Thanks in advance

5万

帖子

99

威望

5万

eV
积分
112354

管理员

公社社长

2#
发表于 Post on 2021-7-13 16:14:44 | 只看该作者 Only view this author
NMA is a singlet molecule, why did you set --uhf 1?
北京科音自然科学研究中心http://www.keinsci.com)致力于计算化学的发展和传播,长期开办高质量的各种计算化学类培训:初级量子化学培训班中级量子化学培训班高级量子化学培训班量子化学波函数分析与Multiwfn程序培训班分子动力学与GROMACS培训班CP2K第一性原理计算培训班,内容介绍以及往届资料购买请点击相应链接查看。这些培训是计算化学从零快速入门以及进一步全面系统性提升研究水平的高速路!培训各种常见问题见《北京科音办的培训班FAQ》
欢迎加入“北京科音”微信公众号获取北京科音培训的最新消息、避免错过网上有价值的计算化学文章!
欢迎加入人气非常高、专业性特别强的综合性理论与计算化学交流QQ群“思想家公社QQ群”:1号:18616395,2号:466017436,3号:764390338,搜索群号能搜到哪个说明目前哪个能加,合计9000人。北京科音培训班的学员在群中可申请VIP头衔,提问将得到群主Sobereva的最优先解答。
思想家公社的门口Blog:http://sobereva.com(发布大量原创计算化学相关博文)
Multiwfn主页:http://sobereva.com/multiwfn(十分强大的量子化学波函数分析程序)
ResearchGate:https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Tian_Lu
Money and papers are rubbish, get a real life!

手机版 Mobile version|北京科音自然科学研究中心 Beijing Kein Research Center for Natural Sciences|京公网安备 11010502035419号|计算化学公社 — 北京科音旗下高水平计算化学交流论坛 ( 京ICP备14038949号-1 )|网站地图

GMT+8, 2024-11-24 06:17 , Processed in 0.168689 second(s), 25 queries , Gzip On.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表 Return to list